The fine itself
A bus lane PCN from City of York Council is £70, reduced to £35 if paid within 21 days. It is a civil penalty — there are no licence points. £70, halved to £35 if paid within 21 days, as both York lane pages already carry from the council's own bus lane enforcement pages. The FOI response did not restate it. The money reported is consistent with it: across five years the council took £851,000 on 43,936 penalties, an average of £19 each, which sits below the £35 discounted rate as it must when income is banked in the year it arrives and a proportion of penalties are cancelled or never paid.
What the council does not hold or publish
- PCNs paid at the discounted rate. The council's previous enforcement system cannot produce a five-year breakdown of how many penalties were paid at the discounted rate, and its current system does not cover the whole period consistently. Because the request asked for nothing that would require manual compilation, the council did not review individual penalty records by hand. There is therefore no way to say what share of York drivers paid £35 rather than £70.
- Challenges, representations and tribunal appeals. Given the same answer: no readily reportable five-year breakdown exists across the council's old and current systems, and producing one would mean interrogating individual case records. Neither the number of drivers who formally challenged a York bus lane penalty nor how many of them won is available. This was not refused under an exemption — the council does not hold it in the form asked for.
- Three months of 2024/25, and a 1,732-penalty disagreement in the council's own figures. The monthly spreadsheet records January, February and March 2025 as "NC" — not collected — at both cameras, so there is no month-by-month picture of that quarter. That leaves the year's total unresolved. The council's letter puts Low Poppleton Lane at 1,926 penalties in 2024/25, but its own monthly sheet for the same year adds up to 194. Every other year reconciles between letter and spreadsheet to the exact penalty at both sites, so this is a single unexplained cell rather than a pattern. The figure used on this page is the 1,926 from the letter, being the council's direct answer to the question asked, but the true 2024/25 total may be up to 1,732 lower.
- When enforcement first began at each camera. The council gave only the date live enforcement recommenced after the equipment was replaced — 1 August 2025 at both sites — and no original start date for either. Both cameras were already issuing penalties in April 2021, where this data begins, so both are older than the figures here show.
- Income to the penny. The council reported income in round thousands — £93k, £113k and so on — rather than exact amounts. Every money figure on this page carries that rounding, so the totals are good to within a few thousand pounds and no closer.
The bus lanes behind these cameras
Each of these locations has a full page with operating hours, permitted vehicles and the governing traffic order: